AmEx offers $300 to Cancel. Huh? – Episode #117

February 23, 2009 by VideoCreditScore-Andy  
Filed under Episodes

AmEx offers $300 to cancel your card

In the latest surprise default driven move, American Express has decided to launch a campaign to get people to cancel their AmEx cards.

Details:

  • $300 gift card
  • You had to be invited. Makes sense, they don’t want their profitable customers to cancel. You should have seen a 14 digit promotion RSVP code

Wow, how can AmEx make more money paying people to leave?

  • What % of cardholders won’t payoff their balances by April 30th, and thus forefeit their opportunity for the $300 gift card. Let’s call it 5%.
  • What % won’t remember the gift card is coming 4 weeks from now. Let’s call it 5%
  • What % won’t use the card at all once received. Let’s call it 5%.
  • What % of the cards unused balances will remain unused. Let’s call it 5%.
  • Thus, only $244 will be invested per closed account. If the 5% rates above grow to 8%, the cost per closure will be $215.

Okay, how can they afford to spend even $215?

AmEx is calculating the cost of default on these accounts. Let’s say 30% of these accounts will default and the average loss is $1000, that means that AmEx loses $300 on average on these accounts. In this math, it’s better for them to spend $215 to get an account off the books, if it will cost them $300 anyway.

Note: all my numbers are speculation, but the logic makes sense. AmEx would only spend this money to close down accounts, if it thought it would lose more money later on.

Similar Posts:

Comments

2 Responses to “AmEx offers $300 to Cancel. Huh? – Episode #117”

  1. Thomas on February 25th, 2009 11:14 pm

    Is this an act of desperation by AMEX? – thanks for mentioning that gift cards are not flexible like money and in the end you end up loosing some of the “incentives” of getting the gift. It almost feels like a fake present.

  2. VideoCreditScore-Andy on February 28th, 2009 1:32 pm

    I find it interesting that most of media ignored this part of the story. Then again, it’s more sensational to discuss the fact they are willing to buy out their least desirable cardholders.

Ask a question, make a comment, share tips